Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
If you’re obsessed with essential oils like I am, you already know how amazing Thieves Oil is. It smells divine, boosts immunity, and cleans like a dream. But let’s be honest—brands like Young Living and DoTerra can leave your wallet crying.
I wrote a Thieves Oil brand comparison post a while back, and the response was HUGE. Many of you loved it, but some of you were… less than thrilled. That’s okay! I appreciate every comment and opinion because it pushed me to keep exploring.
Why I Stopped Buying Young Living Oils
While I do love the quality of Young Living, I couldn’t justify spending $100+ a month to keep up with the rep requirements. And the markup? Yikes. I didn’t want to turn oils into a business—I just wanted affordable wellness.
After testing several brands over the past few years, here are the ones I personally recommend:
🔥 1. Natural Riches Five Guards Essential Oil Blend
💰 Price: ~$14.95
⭐️ Why I love it: This blend has the exact same oils as Young Living’s Thieves and smells nearly identical. Great for diffusing during cold season.
🌿 2.
NOW Nature’s Shield Essential Oil Blend
💰 Price: ~$14.32
🌱 My go-to! This is the one I use daily. It’s potent, pure, and incredibly affordable. If you’re on the fence, this is your best bet.
🌟 3.
Eden’s Garden Fighting Five Blend
💰 Price: ~$18.95
💬 My thoughts: It’s a solid blend, but to me, it doesn’t quite match the aroma of Young Living’s version.
How I Use These Oils
- ✅ In the diffuser when someone’s getting sick
- ✅ Mixed with vinegar and water for an all-purpose spray
- ✅ A few drops on dryer balls for fresh-smelling laundry
- ✅ Added to foot soaks or steam baths for an immunity boost
Final Thoughts
If you’re loyal to Young Living or DoTerra, I totally get it. But if you’re just here for the oil benefits without the price tag or business requirements, these affordable blends are a game-changer.
Have a favorite I didn’t mention? Drop it in the comments! I’d love to hear your go-to oil blends.
