Thieves Oil Brands Comparison: Which Is Best?

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases

🧴 Thieves Oil Brands Comparison: Which Is Best?

Essential oils have exploded in popularity—but how do you know which thieves blend to trust? Whether you’re looking for immune support, home cleaning, or an alternative to synthetic fragrances, we break down the best thieves oil brands on the market.


🥇 Top 3 Thieves Oil Brands

1. Young Living Thieves Essential Oil

  • Blend: Clove, Lemon, Cinnamon Bark, Eucalyptus Radiata, and Rosemary.
  • Best for: Cleaning, immune support.
  • Pros: Highly reputable, concentrated, backed by Seed to Seal® process.
  • Cons: Pricey and only available through distributors.
  • MULTI-USE MIXTURE: A powerful combination of Clove, Lemon, Cinnamon Bark, Eucalyptus, and Rosemary oils, Thieves is a ve…
  • AUTUMN SPICE: Thieves provides an invigorating, spicy cinnamon aroma that purifies the air, freshens the atmosphere, and…
  • NEUTRALIZE ODOR: Mix this blend of natural scents with baking soda to neutralize pet odor in carpets or couches, or add …

2. doTERRA On Guard Protective Blend

  • Blend: Wild Orange, Clove, Cinnamon, Eucalyptus, and Rosemary.
  • Best for: Diffusing, surface spray, oral health.
  • Pros: Warm, spicy scent. Backed by science.
  • Cons: Slightly different than traditional thieves oil; pricing also high.
  • Features a combination of Wild Orange, Clove Bud, Cinnamon, Eucalyptus, and Rosemary essential oils
  • Formulated to support healthy immune function
  • Protects against environmental threats

3. Plant Therapy Germ Fighter

  • Blend: Lemon, Clove Bud, Eucalyptus, Cinnamon Cassia, and Rosemary.
  • Best for: Budget-friendly families.
  • Pros: Third-party tested, great for cleaning & diffusing.
  • Cons: Stronger cinnamon profile; may be irritating to sensitive skin.
  • Batch Specific GC-MS Reports on Every Oil: Every bottle of oil from Plant Therapy goes through multiple rounds of testin…
  • High-Quality Affordable Essential OIls: At Plant Therapy our goal is to positively impact the lives of as many people as…
  • Certified Aromatherapists on Staff: Our Certified Aromatherapists are happy to help you with all of your Essential Oil q…

🧼 Ways to Use Thieves Oil at Home

  • Add to a spray bottle for DIY disinfectant.
  • Diffuse during cold season.
  • Add to homemade toothpaste or mouthwash (check brand safety).
  • Mix into laundry for fresh-smelling clothes.

❓ FAQ About Thieves Oils

Q: Is thieves oil safe for children?

A: Always dilute essential oils before use. Most brands recommend avoiding strong blends for kids under 6.

Q: Can I ingest thieves oil?

A: Some brands like Young Living market for ingestion—but only do so if labeled safe and consult a healthcare provider.

Q: Which brand is best for cleaning?

A: All three work well, but Young Living and Plant Therapy offer great cleaning-specific formulations.

Q: Can I use thieves oil daily?

A: Yes, when diluted properly. Great for diffusing, DIY sprays, or immune-support blends.


📦 Final Thoughts: Which Brand Wins?

If you’re looking for premium quality, go with Young Living. For value and safety, Plant Therapy is fantastic. And if you want a multi-purpose wellness blend, doTERRA On Guard might be your favorite.

Also Read:
1. Thieves Oil That Won’t Break The Bank
2. Essential Oils For Meditation
3. How I’m Surviving Allergy Season With Essential Oils